diff --git a/web/components/anime_card.templ b/web/components/anime_card.templ
index 6522df6..0fda4e6 100644
--- a/web/components/anime_card.templ
+++ b/web/components/anime_card.templ
@@ -24,6 +24,7 @@ type AnimeCardProps struct {
 	TitleJapanese   string
 	Airing          bool
 	WatchlistStatus string // empty if not in watchlist
+	DisableWatchlist bool  // if true, don't render the watchlist button
 }
 
 templ AnimeCard(props AnimeCardProps) {
@@ -91,7 +92,7 @@ templ animeCardPoster(props AnimeCardProps) {
 						</svg>
 					</a>
 				}
-				if !props.CurrentNode {
+				if !props.CurrentNode && !props.DisableWatchlist {
 					@watchlist.CardButton(
 						props.ID,
 						props.Title,
diff --git a/web/templates/continue_watching.templ b/web/templates/continue_watching.templ
index 449eca3..2a29b82 100644
--- a/web/templates/continue_watching.templ
+++ b/web/templates/continue_watching.templ
@@ -23,15 +23,16 @@ templ ContinueWatching(entries []db.GetContinueWatchingEntriesRow) {
 					for _, entry := range entries {
 						<div class="group relative min-w-0" id={ fmt.Sprintf("continue-entry-%d", entry.AnimeID) }>
 						@ui.AnimeCard(ui.AnimeCardProps{
-							ID:              int(entry.AnimeID),
-							Title:           displayContinueWatchingTitle(entry),
-							ImageURL:        entry.ImageUrl,
-							Href:            continueWatchingURL(entry),
-							TitleEnglish:    nullString(entry.TitleEnglish),
-							TitleJapanese:   nullString(entry.TitleJapanese),
-							WatchlistStatus: "watching",
-							Class:           "notification-card min-w-0 flex flex-col bg-transparent text-inherit no-underline",
-							HideTitle:       true,
+							ID:               int(entry.AnimeID),
+							Title:            displayContinueWatchingTitle(entry),
+							ImageURL:         entry.ImageUrl,
+							Href:             continueWatchingURL(entry),
+							TitleEnglish:     nullString(entry.TitleEnglish),
+							TitleJapanese:    nullString(entry.TitleJapanese),
+							WatchlistStatus:  "watching",
+							DisableWatchlist: true,
+							Class:            "notification-card min-w-0 flex flex-col bg-transparent text-inherit no-underline",
+							HideTitle:        true,
 						}) {
 								<div class="mt-2 grid gap-1 p-0">
 									<div class="line-clamp-2 text-sm leading-snug text-(--text)">{ displayContinueWatchingTitle(entry) }</div>